THE SCARIEST COMMANDER! | Disa vs Umbris vs Rendmaw vs The Master of Keys | MTG Commander Gameplay thumbnail Blurred backdrop thumbnail
Perfect Seven profile icon

THE SCARIEST COMMANDER! | Disa vs Umbris vs Rendmaw vs The Master of Keys | MTG Commander Gameplay

Perfect Seven


Commanders featured in this Gameplay Reviewed & Verified

Deck & Commander Strategies

  • The Master of Keys

    The Master of Keys

    Utilizes enchantment spells with reduced costs to fill the graveyard and bring them back to the battlefield for incremental damage while leveraging powerful enchantments like Omniscience and Cathar's Crusade to dominate the board.

  • Rendmaw, Creaking Nest

    Rendmaw, Creaking Nest

    Generates a steady stream of tapped 2/2 bird creature tokens that pressure opponents and encourage combat among them, aiming to overwhelm the board through token swarms and synergy with card types.

  • Disa the Restless

    Disa the Restless

    Focuses on creatures with multiple card types (goifys), using their abilities and synergy to create a large board presence and overrun opponents through combat damage.

  • Umbris, Fear Manifest

    Umbris, Fear Manifest

    Employs blink and mill mechanics centered around horrors and nightmares to disrupt opponents’ libraries while building a graveyard-based advantage.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Master of Keys' strategy of milling key enchantments such as Omniscience and Cathar's Crusade created a potent graveyard setup for recursion and large incremental damage.

  • 2

    Rendmaw's triggered ability to create tapped 2/2 bird tokens upon playing cards with multiple types quickly filled the board and pressured opponents to engage in combat.

  • 3

    Disa's use of multiple card types on creatures synergized well with token generation, amplifying board presence and combat potential.

  • 4

    Targeted removal on key commanders like Grist helped momentarily slow opponents but did not prevent the overwhelming token and enchantment synergy from culminating quickly.

  • 5

    The interplay of graveyard recursion and token swarm mechanics emphasized the value of maintaining board presence and incremental advantage over outright control or combo.

  • 6

    Players balanced aggression and politeness early on, but the escalating board states led to a swift and decisive conclusion driven by creature and enchantment synergies.

Notable Cards

  • Omniscience

    Omniscience

  • Beastmaster Ascension

    Beastmaster Ascension

  • Tarmogoyf

    Tarmogoyf

  • Rendmaw, Creaking Nest

    Rendmaw, Creaking Nest

  • Nyx Weaver

    Nyx Weaver

  • Ripples of Undeath

    Ripples of Undeath

Gameplay Summary

The game featured four players piloting spooky-themed commanders, each with distinct strategies centered around creatures, enchantments, and graveyard interactions.

Early turns saw players developing their mana and board presence with creatures and utility lands, while Rendmaw, Creaking Nest steadily generated tapped 2/2 bird tokens that would later become a significant board presence.

The Master of Keys player quickly leveraged cost reductions on enchantments and milled key cards like Omniscience and Cathar's Crusade into the graveyard, setting up powerful synergies.

As the game progressed, Disa the Restless established a strong presence using the variety of creature card types to trigger token creation and overwhelming board states.

Umbris, Fear Manifest focused on blink and mill effects to control the board while fueling graveyard strategies.

A pivotal moment came when Rendmaw’s ability created a swarm of flying bird tokens, pressuring opponents and advancing board control.

Despite some targeted removal and combat exchanges, the synergy between enchantments and creatures, especially from Master of Keys and Rendmaw, pushed the game toward a swift conclusion.

The game ended quickly as the large goified creatures and numerous tokens overwhelmed defenses, demonstrating the power of tribal synergy and enchantment recursion in a multiplayer setting.

Watch on YouTube