Play to Win profile icon

WHO'S THE BEST LORD OF THE RINGS COMMANDER IN cEDH? - GANDALF vs SAURON vs ARAGORN vs FRODO|SAM

Play to Win

Commanders featured in this video Reviewed & Verified

Deck Strategies

  • Aragorn, the Uniter

    Aragorn, the Uniter

    This deck is a Food Chain combo deck that seeks to win by generating infinite mana with Squee and utilizing the commander for the win.

  • Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit

    Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit

    This is an Abzan Hulk deck using Frodo and Sam, Loyal Attendant as enablers for Cauldron Familiar combo.

  • Sauron, Lord of the Rings

    Sauron, Lord of the Rings

    This is a Grixis combo deck using Sauron as an outlet with Dockside Extortionist and a bounce spell to generate infinite mana.

  • Gandalf the White

    Gandalf the White

    This is a Stax deck that aims to control the board and generate value off of flash speed and doubling ETB effects.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    The use of Reprieve to counter a Toxic Deluge was a significant turning point in the game, effectively nullifying a board wipe while causing substantial loss of tempo for the casting player.

  • 2

    Rhystic Study played a key role in generating card advantage, forcing players to carefully consider whether to allow extra card draw.

  • 3

    The Imperial Seal demonstrated the power of tutor effects in the game, allowing the player to fetch a crucial card at a crucial moment.

  • 4

    The presence of Stax elements like Drannith Magistrate and Archon of Ameria significantly impacted players' strategies, restricting their ability to cast spells and deploy their commanders.

Notable Cards

  • Toxic Deluge

    Toxic Deluge

  • Reprieve

    Reprieve

  • Dockside Extortionist

    Dockside Extortionist

  • Food Chain

    Food Chain

  • Squee

    Squee

  • Cauldron Familiar

    Cauldron Familiar

  • Rhystic Study

    Rhystic Study

  • Imperial Seal

    Imperial Seal

Summary

This gameplay featured a clash of powerful commanders from the Lord of the Rings universe. The match saw significant interaction between decks and effective use of counter play. Early in the game, the players focused on setting up their mana bases and establishing initial threats. However, the game quickly escalated with the deployment of potent combo pieces, deck-specific engines, and strategic counter-measures. A pivotal moment occurred when a Toxic Deluge, intended to clear the board, was countered by a Reprieve, wasting a significant amount of resources and tempo. Despite attempts to establish field dominance, the game ended inconclusively due to the nature of the transcript.