Things in the Ice profile icon

Who's Your Favorite Moist Commander? [cEDH Gameplay] PLAGON v REV v TYMNA|THRASIOS v GLARB

Things in the Ice

Commanders featured in this video Reviewed & Verified

Decklists

Deck Strategies

  • Rev, Tithe Extractor

    Rev, Tithe Extractor

    An aggressive treasure-focused deck that uses combat damage to generate treasure tokens for mana ramp and spellcasting, aiming to overwhelm opponents with resource advantage and synergistic threats.

  • Thrasios, Triton Hero Tymna the Weaver

    Tymna the Weaver / Thrasios, Triton Hero

    A value and interaction deck that leverages card draw from combat damage and uses protective creatures like Grand Abolisher to enable uncounterable spells and control the board with disruption.

  • Glarb, Calamity's Augur

    Glarb, Calamity's Augur

    A control and disruption deck focusing on counterspells and removal to slow down opponents’ combos and maintain board presence while leveraging synergies to protect resources.

  • Plagon, Lord of the Beach

    Plagon, Lord of the Beach

    A ramp and tempo deck that uses treasure token generation and synergistic spells to accelerate mana and apply pressure through efficient creatures and powerful activated abilities.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Rev used combat damage triggers multiple times in a single combat step to generate a large number of treasure tokens, fueling explosive mana production.

  • 2

    Players coordinated removal and counterspells to prevent a potential win on Steve’s turn, highlighting the importance of interaction in cEDH.

  • 3

    The use of Path of Exile to exile problematic permanents like Linia was a key strategic move to disrupt opponents’ plans and open opportunities for counterplay.

  • 4

    Grand Abolisher’s presence was significant for protecting uncounterable spells but losing it weakened Tymna|Thrasios’ control over the stack.

  • 5

    The synergy between treasure tokens and activated abilities was pivotal in ramping and enabling high-impact plays quickly.

Notable Cards

  • Rev, Tithe Extractor

    Rev, Tithe Extractor

  • Grand Abolisher

    Grand Abolisher

  • Mental Misstep

    Mental Misstep

  • Devoted Druid

    Devoted Druid

  • Exotic Orchard

    Exotic Orchard

Summary

The game features a competitive four-player Commander match with Rev, Tithe Extractor; Tymna the Weaver paired with Thrasios, Triton Hero; Glarb, Calamity's Augur; and Plagon, Lord of the Beach. Early game plays involved setting up mana acceleration and board presence, with Rev deploying Grim Harlequin and using aggressive attacks combined with treasure token generation to gain both board control and resources. Tymna|Thrasios focused on card draw and interaction, leveraging creatures like Grand Abolisher to protect key plays, but eventually lost Grand Abolisher to removal, weakening their ability to protect spells. Glarb used disruption and counterspells to hinder opponents’ combos, while Plagon capitalized on treasure generation and synergistic spells to ramp and pressure opponents. A turning point occurred when Rev's aggressive treasure production and combat damage generated a significant mana advantage, enabling explosive plays such as casting Glarb and activating powerful abilities. Strategic use of exile effects, such as Path of Exile targeting key threats, and well-timed counterspells and removal shaped the evolving board state. The game saw critical moments involving interaction around Linia and attempts to prevent a win on Steve’s turn, with players coordinating to manage threats. Ultimately, the dynamic interplay of treasure tokens, removal, and counterspells defined the late game tension as players jockeyed for control and tried to secure the win condition through combat damage and mana-fueled spellcasting.

Description

IS IT SUMMER YET?

We will be at the Chicago Magiccon Feb. 21st - 23rd. Hope to see you there!

WE HAVE A PATREOOOOOOOOON!!! We appreciate support at every level and you can get some really neat benefits!

www.patreon.com/thingsintheice/membership

AND WE ALSO HAVE A DISCORD!! Come on down and help us build a fun, loving, weird, little community around this awesome game we all enjoy!

discord.gg/Jye88qXcDw

You can find our merch at www.bonfire.com/store/things-in-the-ice

Playmat art by Geeked Up Alters www.etsy.com/shop/GeekedUpAlters

Orc Army and Treasure tokens by Inklin Customs www.inklincustoms.com

John on cEDH TV’s Rev, Tithe Extractor: moxfield.com/decks/256HIjQ6u0mmBxTHOqXTIg

Steve on Tymna|Thrasios: moxfield.com/decks/lKm78dSuLE6n3-kQiQ7T6Q

Kyle on Glarb: moxfield.com/decks/80mGkd0tjU2rt0f4YYHDjw

Jeremy on Comedian’s Plagon: moxfield.com/decks/xHcBia4hnUOksQsXobCBnQ

Music by High Fashion Wigs

#mtg #cedh #edh #magicthegathering #commander