The Dankest Dungeon profile icon

RE-MATCH! Gandalf, Treebeard, Bilbo, Peregrin | Lord of the Rings Commander Gameplay

The Dankest Dungeon

Commanders featured in this video Reviewed & Verified

Deck Strategies

  • Gandalf the White

    Gandalf the White

    Utilizes flash creatures and instant-speed spells to control the board, generate card advantage, and disrupt opponents through targeted removal and flexible responses.

  • Treebeard, Gracious Host

    Treebeard, Gracious Host

    Focuses on life gain and creating a wide board of tokens, using creatures and spells that synergize with life gain to outlast opponents.

  • Bilbo, Birthday Celebrant

    Bilbo, Birthday Celebrant

    Leverages incremental life gain and board presence, using creatures that generate value each turn and survive through durability and resilience.

  • Peregrin Took

    Peregrin Took

    Builds a token and artifact-based engine centered on food tokens and +1/+1 counters to grow creatures and gain life, enabling sustained combat pressure and synergy.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Gandalf's ability to flash in creatures and cast removal spells at instant speed allowed him to maintain control and pressure multiple opponents simultaneously.

  • 2

    The synergy between food tokens and +1/+1 counters in Peregrin's deck created sustained growth and life gain, making his board state increasingly threatening.

  • 3

    Treebeard's life gain strategy helped mitigate early aggression but lacked sufficient offensive power to close the game against ramping opponents.

  • 4

    Bilbo's steady life gain and durable creatures enabled him to stabilize the board, providing resilience against removal-heavy decks.

  • 5

    Using artifacts like Soul Ring and Cryptolith Rite early accelerated mana development, enabling faster deployment of threats and combos.

  • 6

    Players utilized combat tricks and blockers effectively to manage commander damage and prevent early eliminations.

  • 7

    The presence of taxing effects like Thalia slowed down non-creature spells, impacting some players' mana curves and strategic options.

Notable Cards

  • Thalia, Guardian of Thraben

    Thalia, Guardian of Thraben

  • Essence Warden

    Essence Warden

  • Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit

    Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit

  • Foundry Inspector

    Foundry Inspector

  • Cryptolith Rite

    Cryptolith Rite

  • Spike Feeder

    Spike Feeder

  • Skullclamp

    Skullclamp

  • Portable Hole

    Portable Hole

  • Sensei's Divining Top

    Sensei's Divining Top

Summary

The game featured a dynamic clash between four distinct Lord of the Rings-themed commanders, each leveraging unique synergies. Early turns involved ramping mana and setting up board presence with creatures that generate life, food tokens, and card advantage. Treebeard focused on life gain and token generation, while Bilbo emphasized incremental life gain and board development. Gandalf the White flashed in creatures and utilized spells to control the board, and Peregrin Took built a synergistic token and artifact-based engine with interactions around food and counters. Midgame saw key interactions such as Gandalf using his ability to pick multiple targets for removal spells, disrupting opponents' plans. Bilbo and Peregrin capitalized on food tokens and +1/+1 counter synergies to grow their board states and generate value. Treebeard's life-gain strategy helped him survive early aggression but struggled against the growing threats. The game reached a turning point when Peregrin executed a strong combat phase leveraging food tokens and life gain to pressure opponents, while Gandalf maintained control with flash creatures and targeted removal. The match showcased intricate interplay of life gain, token generation, and flash tactics, with each player attempting to outmaneuver others through resource management and combat tricks.

Description

Let’s have another go with Gandalf the White vs. Treebeard, Generous Host vs. Bilbo, Birthday Celebrant vs. Peregrin Took!

If you like this content and would like access to our full deck lists please consider supporting the channel through Patreon at www.patreon.com/dankestdungeon