Staring Into the Eye of the Cloaca | Winter vs. Hope vs. Go-Shintai vs. Choco thumbnail Blurred backdrop thumbnail

Staring Into the Eye of the Cloaca | Winter vs. Hope vs. Go-Shintai vs. Choco

Guild Pack profile icon
Guild Pack 72 EDH Gameplay videos

Commanders featured in this Gameplay Reviewed & Verified

Decklists

Deck & Commander Strategies

  • Winter, Cynical Opportunist

    Winter, Cynical Opportunist

    Build a diverse graveyard to enable Winter’s ability to exile cards with multiple types and put powerful permanents onto the battlefield with finality counters, focusing on a bug tribal theme to maintain board presence.

  • Hope Estheim

    Hope Estheim

    Gain life to mill opponents’ libraries, leveraging incremental advantage from milling and life gain while controlling the board with bounce and removal spells.

  • Go-Shintai of Life's Origin

    Go-Shintai of Life's Origin

    Create shrine tokens and repeatedly recur enchantments from the graveyard to the battlefield, generating value and board presence through enchantment synergies.

  • Choco, Seeker of Paradise

    Choco, Seeker of Paradise

    Utilize a bird tribal deck that synergizes with landfall, drawing cards and putting lands onto the battlefield to grow creatures and maintain card advantage.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Authority of the Consuls effectively slowed down aggressive strategies by tapping creatures as they entered the battlefield, impacting tempo early on.

  • 2

    Winter’s end step ability to exile cards with four or more card types allowed for powerful permanents to enter the battlefield with finality counters, creating a strong board presence.

  • 3

    The use of Haywire Might to destroy Authority of the Consuls was a strategic removal, but Hope’s Cyclonic Rift bounced it back, showing how blue’s interaction can disrupt opponents' plans.

  • 4

    Choco’s ability to put bird tokens onto the battlefield with finality counters after attacking helped maintain a growing and resilient board state.

  • 5

    The synergy between graveyard recursion and token generation proved to be a key factor in maintaining tempo and board control.

  • 6

    Life gain from enchantment spells and creatures like Cyclists the Harvest Hand provided steady card advantage and enabled Hope’s milling strategy.

Notable Cards

  • Authority of the Consuls

    Authority of the Consuls

  • Cyclonic Rift

    Cyclonic Rift

  • Wingmate Roc

    Wingmate Roc

  • Deathcap Cultivator

    Deathcap Cultivator

Gameplay Summary

The game began with players establishing their mana bases and early board presence, with key enchantments and creatures entering play.

Authority of the Consuls was deployed early, slowing down aggressive strategies by tapping opponents' creatures as they entered the battlefield.

Winter, Cynical Opportunist focused on building a graveyard with diverse card types to leverage its powerful ability to put permanents onto the battlefield with finality counters.

Hope Estheim employed a life gain and milling mechanic that synergized well with opponents’ graveyards, while Go-Shintai of Life's Origin created shrine tokens and recurred enchantments from the graveyard, generating incremental value.

Choco, Seeker of Paradise centered on a bird tribal strategy, leveraging landfall and card advantage through attacking with birds and playing lands from the top of the library. A pivotal moment occurred when Soulcatcher’s airy started enhancing all birds on Choco’s side, increasing their power and creating a threatening board state.

Another key interaction involved Haywire Might destroying Authority of the Consuls, only for Hope to bounce it back with Cyclonic Rift, showcasing the blue player's control capabilities.

Combat began shaping the board state significantly when Choco attacked, triggering the ability to put additional birds onto the battlefield with finality counters, further pressuring opponents. Throughout the game, players balanced aggressive board development with strategic disruption and recursion.

The combination of graveyard recursion, life gain milling, and tokens created multiple win conditions, but the game remained dynamic with players constantly interacting through removal and bounce spells.

The synergy between finality counters and token generation was especially impactful in maintaining board presence and tempo.

Watch on YouTube