(EDH) Ghoulcaller Gisa VS Atraxa

Decklists

Deck & Commander Strategies

Ghoulcaller Gisa
Mono-black zombie tribal focused on sacrificing creatures to reanimate powerful zombies, generating tokens, and draining life through synergies with creatures like Shieldred and Crib Breaker.
Atraxa, Praetors' Voice
Proliferate and +1/+1 counters strategy that grows creatures and permanents over time, utilizing spells and creatures that add counters, then finishing with a massive board-wide buff and combat advantage.

Gameplay Insights

1
Sacrificing Atraxa to Gisa's ability to generate zombies was a key interaction, but Atraxa's board growth and proliferate effects allowed her to recover and overwhelm.
2
Forgetting to proliferate on some turns slightly slowed Atraxa's growth but did not prevent the eventual large board state.
3
Using Coalition Relic and Green Sun's Zenith enabled Atraxa to ramp quickly and fetch crucial creatures, accelerating her strategy.
4
Final of the Visitation cast with a high X value created a lethal swing by granting massive buffs and multiple keywords to all creatures.
5
Gisa's token and zombie generation provided good pressure but lacked the necessary removal or disruption to handle Atraxa's overwhelming board state.

Notable Cards

Ghoulcaller Gisa
Atraxa, Praetors' Voice
Green Sun's Zenith
Coalition Relic
Bloodline Keeper // Lord of Lineage

Gameplay Summary

The game featured a tense duel between two distinct strategies: Ghoulcaller Gisa's mono-black zombie tribal and Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's proliferate and +1/+1 counter synergy.

Early turns saw both players developing their mana bases and deploying key creatures, with Gisa focusing on recurring zombies like Shieldred and Crib Breaker, while Atraxa built up a massive Hydra and utilized proliferate to grow her board.

Atraxa leveraged powerful spells such as Green Sun's Zenith and Coalition Relic to ramp and fetch impactful creatures, steadily increasing board presence. A pivotal moment occurred when Atraxa cast Final of the Visitation with a large X value, buffing her entire board with a massive +11/+11 and multiple keywords, enabling a decisive combat phase that overwhelmed Gisa.

Despite Gisa's resilient zombies and token generation, she was unable to find timely answers, especially after Atraxa successfully resolved key enchantments and creatures like Master Geomancer and Sirrolis.

Atraxa's combination of board-wide buffs, lifelink, and evasion secured the victory, showcasing the strength of proliferate and counters in a 1v1 EDH setting.

Watch on YouTube