Witherbloom VS Lorehold VS Silverquill VS Killan Secrets of Strixhaven Commander Gameplay thumbnail Blurred backdrop thumbnail

Witherbloom VS Lorehold VS Silverquill VS Killan Secrets of Strixhaven Commander Gameplay

MTG Muddstah profile icon
MTG Muddstah 1114 EDH Gameplay videos

Commanders featured in this Gameplay Reviewed & Verified

Decklists

Deck & Commander Strategies

  • Silverquill, the Disputant

    Silverquill, the Disputant

    Token generation combined with spell copying via casualty to control the board and drain opponents, while recurring creatures like Nadier's Nightblade to gain life and card advantage.

  • Witherbloom, the Balancer

    Witherbloom, the Balancer

    Token production with sacrifice outlets to create board presence and value, using creatures like Namata and spells that generate pest tokens to swarm opponents.

  • Killian, Decisive Mentor

    Killian, Decisive Mentor

    Enchant opponents' creatures or lands to create goat tokens and generate incremental advantage through extort and synergy with token producers.

  • Lorehold, the Historian

    Lorehold, the Historian

    Aggressive land ramp and creature deployment supported by spells and enchantments that provide direct damage and board control, capitalizing on Land Tax for resource consistency.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Arj's use of Killian's ability to enchant opponents' permanents and generate goats created a steady stream of tokens that applied pressure and synergy with extort triggered multiple life drains and life gain.

  • 2

    Max effectively used Silverquill's casualty ability to repeatedly copy powerful spells like Reanimate and Vandal's Edit, enabling both graveyard recursion and board wipes while draining opponents via Nadier's Nightblade.

  • 3

    Sammy's token swarm from Witherbloom took advantage of sacrifice synergies, but board states like Blind Obedience and Changing Loyalty hindered token effectiveness by tapping creatures and stealing tokens when sacrificed.

  • 4

    Matt leveraged Land Tax repeatedly to ensure steady land drops, enabling him to cast impactful creatures and enchantments like Cool But Rude and Sigil of the Empty Throne, which generated flying tokens and increased board presence.

  • 5

    A critical moment was Max's play of Perch Protection to gain protection and an extra turn, securing a massive life gain and damage output that eliminated Sammy and shifted momentum.

  • 6

    Arj's use of Rune of Mortality combined with Path to Exile was a strategic removal sequence to efficiently handle threats like Benny Bra while still generating value from Killian's abilities.

  • 7

    Token combat exchanges often resulted in sacrifices and triggers that further advanced board states, exemplifying the synergy between token production, death triggers, and life drain effects.

Notable Cards

  • Killian, Decisive Mentor

    Killian, Decisive Mentor

  • Welcoming Vampire

    Welcoming Vampire

  • Nadier's Nightblade

    Nadier's Nightblade

  • Cool but Rude

    Cool but Rude

  • Sigil of the Empty Throne

    Sigil of the Empty Throne

  • Blind Obedience

    Blind Obedience

  • Vanishing Verse

    Vanishing Verse

  • Fabled Passage

    Fabled Passage

Gameplay Summary

The game began with a typical slow mana ramp and land setup from all four players, each establishing their board presence through various utility lands and early creatures.

Killian, Decisive Mentor quickly became a pivotal commander as Arj utilized its abilities to create goat tokens and generate value by enchanting opponents' permanents.

Sammy's Witherbloom deck focused on creating numerous tokens and using sacrifice synergies, exemplified by casting Namata and producing pest tokens, though his board was hampered by enchantments like Blind Obedience.

Max's Silverquill deck centered on token generation and spell copying, leveraging cards like Welcoming Vampire and using casualty to recur threats like Nadier's Nightblade for life drain and card draw.

Matt's Lorehold deck employed Land Tax for consistent land drops and used aggressive creatures and enchantments, including Cool But Rude and Sigil of the Empty Throne, to pressure the table.

Watch on YouTube