HOB vs. LTR: Which Commanders are More Powerful? | Aragorn vs. Smaug vs. Sauron vs. Thranduil thumbnail Blurred backdrop thumbnail

HOB vs. LTR: Which Commanders are More Powerful? | Aragorn vs. Smaug vs. Sauron vs. Thranduil

Guild Pack profile icon
Guild Pack 99 EDH Gameplay videos

∙

Commanders featured in this Gameplay Reviewed & Verified

Decklists

Deck & Commander Strategies

  • Smaug the Magnificent

    Smaug the Magnificent

    Generate treasure tokens each turn to fuel Smaug's attack damage, dealing massive direct damage to opponents while leveraging haste and flying for aggressive board control.

  • Sauron, the Dark Lord

    Sauron, the Dark Lord

    Amass a growing orc army through opponent spell triggers, use the ring's tempt ability to cycle cards efficiently, and overwhelm opponents with combat damage and card advantage.

  • Thranduil, the Elvenking

    Thranduil, the Elvenking

    Exploit elf synergies by copying activated abilities of elves in the graveyard, draw cards when legendary elves enter, and maintain steady card advantage to outvalue opponents.

  • Aragorn, the Uniter

    Aragorn, the Uniter

    Cast spells of multiple colors to generate human soldier tokens, scry, deal direct damage, and pump creatures, combining these effects to build a versatile and resilient board presence.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Smaug's treasure token generation combined with equipment like Diamond Pickaxe allowed for explosive attacks with flying haste, maximizing damage output rapidly.

  • 2

    Sauron's ability to amass orcs on opponent spell casts and the ring tempt mechanic provided continuous card draw, enabling sustained pressure and board development.

  • 3

    Thranduil's draw engine triggered by legendary elf entries and copying elf abilities from the graveyard helped maintain card advantage and board presence.

  • 4

    Aragorn's multi-color spellcasting triggered multiple beneficial effects simultaneously—token generation, scrying, damage, and pumping—making him a versatile threat that required opponents' attention.

  • 5

    Returning lands from the graveyard to the battlefield via spells helped maintain mana stability and accelerate midgame plays.

  • 6

    Players coordinated blocking and damage assignments carefully, highlighting the importance of timing and resource management in multiplayer Commander games.

Notable Cards

  • Smaug the Magnificent

    Smaug the Magnificent

  • Sauron, the Dark Lord

    Sauron, the Dark Lord

  • Thranduil, the Elvenking

    Thranduil, the Elvenking

  • Aragorn, the Uniter

    Aragorn, the Uniter

  • Alchemist's Talent

    Alchemist's Talent

  • Aftermath Analyst

    Aftermath Analyst

  • Trace of Abundance

    Trace of Abundance

Gameplay Summary

The game features four players each piloting powerful commanders from The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings MTG sets, creating an intense multiplayer battle.

Early turns saw players establishing mana bases and starting to deploy their strategies.

Smaug the Magnificent's player began generating treasure tokens to fuel massive damage output, equipping Smaug with artifact buffs to turn him into a devastating flying attacker.

Meanwhile, Sauron the Dark Lord built up an orc army and leveraged the ring's draw and discard mechanics to maintain card advantage. Thranduil, the Elvenking, focused on elf synergy by activating abilities from elves in the graveyard and drawing cards when legendary elves entered the battlefield, accelerating his hand and board development.

Aragorn, the Uniter, utilized spells of different colors to create tokens, scry, deal damage, and pump his creatures, aiming to unite his forces for powerful attacks.

Key turning points included Smaug's explosive treasure generation and attack phases, Sauron's army buildup and card draw, and Aragorn's multiple color synergies creating combat threats.

The game revolved around board presence, resource generation, and timing crucial attacks, with Smaug's treasure-fueled damage and Aragorn's multi-color spells standing out as major win condition drivers.

Watch on YouTube