CEDH Magic the Gathering Gameplay Is Smothering Tithe OP!? Ft Blight Club

Deck Strategies

• 

  Tymna the Weaver

  Utilizes combat damage to draw cards, leveraging evasive creatures and partner synergy to generate card advantage and pressure opponents.

• 

  Tevesh Szat, Doom of Fools

  Focuses on instants and sorceries to generate value and control the board, often using discard and recursion elements to maintain advantage.

• 

  Volrath, the Shapestealer

  Exploits Volrath's ability to steal and copy key creatures on opponents’ boards, turning enemy resources against them for board dominance.

• 

  Francisco, Fowl Marauder

  Combines aggressive pirate tribal synergies with disruption and tempo plays, aiming to win through combat damage and incremental advantage.

• 

  Rielle, the Everwise

  Draws cards by casting instants and sorceries, leveraging graveyard and spell recursion to build a large hand and control the game’s pace.

Gameplay Insights

• 1

  The early deployment of Smothering Tithe forced opponents to pay heavy taxes or allow treasure generation, significantly ramping mana for the Tithe controller.

• 2

  Blood Moon disrupted multicolor mana bases but was efficiently removed to prevent long-term mana lock.

• 3

  Players carefully timed artifact destruction, such as Scorch Earth, to limit explosive mana acceleration from artifacts like Mana Vault and Chrome Mox.

• 4

  Deflecting Swat was cleverly used to redirect Smothering Tithe triggers, effectively doubling treasure token generation and accelerating resource gain.

• 5

  Volrath’s ability to steal creatures provided a flexible threat that pressured opponents’ boards and disrupted their strategies.

• 6

  Multiple instances of mana denial and tax payment decisions highlighted the importance of resource management in this cEDH game.

Notable Cards

• 

  Smothering Tithe

• 

  Mana Vault

• 

  Chrome Mox

• 

  Blood Moon

• 

  Deflecting Swat

• 

  Cursed Totem

Summary

The game began with a slow ramp-up phase where players established their mana bases and early board presence. Key artifacts like Mana Vault, Chrome Mox, and Smothering Tithe generated significant advantage early on, setting the stage for explosive plays. A pivotal moment occurred when a Blood Moon was cast, disrupting color fixing and slowing down some players, though it was later removed with Nature's Claim. Smothering Tithe proved to be a major threat, as its tax created treasure tokens that accelerated mana production, fueling larger spells and combos. Players engaged in tactical interactions involving resource denial and board control, including Scorch Earth to disrupt artifact mana and strategic use of tutors to find crucial answers. Volrath, the Shapestealer leveraged his ability to steal key creatures, while Tymna the Weaver players focused on drawing cards through combat damage and activation effects. The game featured multiple responses and counters, such as Deflecting Swat used on Smothering Tithe triggers to maximize treasure generation. The win condition appeared to revolve around assembling a critical mass of resources and card advantage to overwhelm opponents with efficient creatures and combos.