WHOS THE BEST COMMANDER FROM CRIMSON VOW IN cEDH? Grolnok | Old Rutstein | Anje | Toxrill

Deck Strategies

• 

  Old Rutstein

  Generate value and board presence through food tokens and creatures like Dark Confidant, enabling incremental card advantage and resilience.

• 

  Anje, Maid of Dishonor

  Utilize a reanimator combo with Worldgorger Dragon and Underworld Breach to exile and return permanents, aiming for a massive board reset and advantage.

• 

  Toxrill, the Corrosive

  Leverage slime counters and Forbidden Orchard to create slug tokens that provide card draw and sacrifice outlets, enabling a slow but consistent value engine and attrition.

• 

  Grolnok, the Omnivore

  Use artifact ramp and sacrifice synergies with tokens to apply pressure and maintain board control.

Gameplay Insights

• 1

  The use of Forbidden Orchard to generate slug tokens via Toxrill’s toxic ability was a subtle but effective synergy providing repeated card draw and board presence.

• 2

  Anje’s Worldgorger Dragon combo was disrupted by a timely slime counter triggered board wipe and Gilded Drake stealing the key creature, illustrating the importance of interaction timing.

• 3

  Holding counterspell mana prior to casting major spells like Finale of Devastation can be a crucial deterrent, influencing opponents' plays and protecting key lines.

• 4

  Sacrificing tokens to draw cards while managing toxic counters created complex stack interactions that required precise sequencing to maximize value.

• 5

  The interaction of multiple triggered abilities on the stack (toxic slime counters, slug generation) demonstrated the depth of timing and order of operations in high-level cEDH gameplay.

Notable Cards

• 

  Worldgorger Dragon

• 

  Underworld Breach

• 

  Forbidden Orchard

• 

  Cabal Ritual

• 

  Finale of Devastation

• 

  Gilded Drake

• 

  Dark Confidant

• 

  Mana Vault

• 

  Mox Diamond

• 

  Phantasmal Image

Summary

The multiplayer Commander game featured four Crimson Vow commanders each employing unique strategies. Early turns saw typical ramp and setup plays including casting key mana artifacts and dropping commanders to establish board presence. The Old Rutstein deck focused on food token generation and value creatures like Dark Confidant, while the Anje, Maid of Dishonor player pursued a world-gorger combo reanimator approach using cards like Underworld Breach and Entomb to cheat out Worldgorger Dragon and trigger a devastating board reset. The Toxrill, the Corrosive deck utilized slime counters and a synergy with Forbidden Orchard to generate slug tokens that also provided card draw, creating a slow attrition and value engine. Grolnok, the Omnivore leveraged artifact mana sources and aggression with tokens and sacrifice outlets. A critical turning point came when Anje attempted to execute her combo with Worldgorger Dragon, only to be disrupted by a Slime Counter triggered board wipe and Gilded Drake stealing the key creature, which hindered Anje’s follow-through. Meanwhile, Toxrill’s interaction with Forbidden Orchard and repeated sacrifice of slugs for card draw maintained steady value and pressure. Finale of Devastation was cast as a major threat, prompting opponents to respond carefully, with one player holding counter spells to try and stop it. Strategic use of counterspells, sacrifice outlets, and timing of triggers around toxic slime counters and slug tokens created complex stack interactions that shaped the board state. The game revolved around managing these synergies and combos, with players constantly trading resources and leveraging their commanders’ unique abilities to gain incremental advantage.