Play to Win profile icon

WHAT'S THE BEST THRASIOS DECK IN cEDH? Featuring ComedIAN MTG - Play to Win Gameplay

Play to Win

Commanders featured in this video Reviewed & Verified

Decklists

Deck Strategies

  • Thrasios, Triton Hero

    Thrasios, Triton Hero

    A value-driven deck focused on incremental advantage through efficient mana ramp, card selection, and interaction to out-resource opponents and eventually close out the game with a powerful combo or overwhelming board presence.

  • Bruse Tarl, Boorish Herder

    Bruse Tarl, Boorish Herder

    Midrange aggressive deck leveraging combat damage triggers to gain life and push damage through double strike, supported by efficient creatures and some interaction to maintain pressure.

  • Vial Smasher the Fierce

    Vial Smasher the Fierce

    A Jund-based control and disruption deck that uses powerful removal, discard, and counterspells to control the board while applying pressure through Vial Smasher’s damage triggers.

  • Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy

    Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy

    A combo-centric deck that accelerates mana production exponentially using Kinnan’s ability to generate massive mana, which is then converted into a win through established combo pieces.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Using Force of Negation to counter a Swan Song on an important protection spell was crucial in preserving tempo and turning the tide of interaction.

  • 2

    Deflecting Swat's redirection was expertly used to turn opponents’ removal spells back against themselves, highlighting the importance of flexible interaction in cEDH.

  • 3

    Carpet of Flowers was repeatedly leveraged to generate significant mana advantage on opponents’ turns, enabling explosive plays and mana-intensive spells.

  • 4

    Players balanced aggressive combat damage with life gain and board control, exemplified by Bruse Tarl’s double strike and lifelink triggers, emphasizing the role of combat in midrange strategies.

  • 5

    The intense back-and-forth over resolving a Rift spell demonstrated how important timing and priority sequencing are in high-level interaction-heavy games.

  • 6

    Efficient mana ramp and card draw engines like Sylvan Library and Bloom Tender were key to maintaining resource parity and enabling complex plays.

Notable Cards

  • Force of Negation

    Force of Negation

  • Deflecting Swat

    Deflecting Swat

  • Veil of Summer

    Veil of Summer

  • Carpet of Flowers

    Carpet of Flowers

  • Sylvan Library

    Sylvan Library

  • Green Sun's Zenith

    Green Sun's Zenith

  • Pongify

    Pongify

  • Manifold Insights

    Manifold Insights

  • Birds of Paradise

    Birds of Paradise

  • Bloom Tender

    Bloom Tender

Summary

The game featured four competitive decks centered around Thrasios and other strong commanders, each employing different strategies to gain an advantage. Early turns saw fast mana development with multiple utility lands, mana dorks like Birds of Paradise, and value engines such as Sylvan Library and Carpet of Flowers. The players engaged in heavy interaction, with multiple counters, removal spells like Pongify, and redirection effects such as Deflecting Swat shifting the momentum back and forth. Notably, a player was able to counter a Swan Song with Force of Negation, showcasing the high level of interaction and importance of protecting critical spells. Midgame revolved around incremental value from mana acceleration and card draw, with players using effects like Manifold Insights and green Sun's Zenith to fetch key pieces. Combat damage was leveraged to trigger life gain and double strike, furthering board presence. Attempts at combo or win conditions were repeatedly disrupted by opponents’ interaction. A pivotal moment was an intense clash over a Rift spell where multiple counters and redirections were attempted, illustrating the tense control dynamics. Despite the aggressive board state and multiple threats, the game remained a careful balance of tempo and resource management as players jockeyed to establish a winning position.

Description

Today we have Ian from ComedIAN MTG on so we decided to play our favorite green based decks and see which one has what it takes.

WE HAVE

Advantage Thrasios - At its core, Advantage Thrasios acts as an Adaptive/Disruptive deck that looks to eventually play more magic than the rest of the table, with as few dead cards as possible. www.moxfield.com/decks/Vgs4QBUKVkGbKyypaoMZsg

Dawnwaker Thrasios - Ian’s Bruse/Thrasios Midrange list that has changed slightly since this filming, but all his updates are in the primer. It shares many similarities to Advantage but would probably be described as faster, while losing some interaction. www.moxfield.com/decks/kLygDHVCskGtvwAWsL2MNw

Curiosity Control -Cam’s 4 color pile of cEDH version of Jund is what this deck is, really. It’s just a jund deck, except the cEDH version. www.moxfield.com/decks/bRzBzd6WkUad4ZM-zPWKCw

Kinnan Combo -Tyler is a card or two off from this list, but the plan remains the same. Use kinnan to make buckets of mana until you can convert it into a win. www.moxfield.com/decks/O7RMsRcwN0uyxGp9et_L2g

Check out ComedIAN MTG here - www.youtube.com/channel/UCgQKCaY35CL8M99Ysa1N7Rg

Check out game 2 on his channel - youtu.be/nMI9uKKk0hY

BUY SHIRTS HERE - www.bonfire.com/store/play-to-win

PATREON - patreon.com/playtowin?utm_med

PLAY MATS / NEW TOKENS - www.playtowinmtg.com/merch

TCG PLAYER AFFILIATE LINK - shop.tcgplayer.com/magic/product?utm_campaign=affiliate&utm_medium=PlayToWinMTG&utm_source=PlayToWinMTG

TOKENS/DONATE HERE- blacklivesmatters.carrd.co -Then forward us the receipt to [email protected] -Include your mailing address, and we’ll send you a pack of four of our custom treasure tokens.

PODCAST Spotify! - open.spotify.com/show/0jkKhZ9qD0T1bkihEzjn2K

PODCAST iTunes! - podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/play-to-win-podcast/id1527842263

TWITTER - @playtowinmtg

INSTAGRAM - @playtowinmtg

Link for iOS Lifetap app: apps.apple.com/us/app/lifetap-life-tracker-for-mtg/id1508241754

Link for Android Lifetap app: play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.lifetap