Who’s the DEADLIEST Kindred Commander?! – Shelob vs The First Sliver vs Gisa & Geralf vs Ureni thumbnail Blurred backdrop thumbnail

Who’s the DEADLIEST Kindred Commander?! – Shelob vs The First Sliver vs Gisa & Geralf vs Ureni

Manasplaining profile icon
Manasplaining 49 EDH Gameplay videos

Commanders featured in this Gameplay Reviewed & Verified

Deck & Commander Strategies

  • Shelob, Child of Ungoliant

    Shelob, Child of Ungoliant

    Focuses on spider creatures with reach to control the board defensively, using blockers to deter opponents’ flying attacks while building up to a late-game advantage through high toughness and combat tricks.

  • The First Sliver

    The First Sliver

    Aggressively floods the board with slivers, granting them flying to dominate the skies and outpace opponents through synergy and evasion, aiming to win via aerial combat damage.

  • Gisa and Geralf

    Gisa and Geralf

    Utilizes milling to fill the graveyard and cast zombie creatures from it repeatedly, creating a resilient and growing horde of undead that can pressure opponents relentlessly.

  • Ureni of the Unwritten

    Ureni of the Unwritten

    Leverages ramp and dragon tribal synergies to deploy powerful flying dragons that gain life and attack aggressively, using Chaos Dragon’s unique combat effect to control attack targets and sway combat dynamics.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    The First Sliver’s flying buff forced opponents reliant on ground defense and reach to reconsider their blocking strategies immediately.

  • 2

    Gisa and Geralf’s milling and graveyard recursion proved pivotal in maintaining board presence and threatening continual zombie waves.

  • 3

    Chaos Dragon’s roll-the-dice mechanic during combat introduced unpredictable attack restrictions, influencing player targeting decisions and combat outcomes.

  • 4

    Early ramp and mana fixing, such as using Cultivate and Cavern of Souls, allowed players to efficiently cast tribal creatures and maintain pressure.

  • 5

    The spider deck’s reliance on reach creatures gave it defensive strength but struggled against widespread flying threats from slivers and dragons.

Notable Cards

  • Chaos Dragon

    Chaos Dragon

  • The First Sliver

    The First Sliver

  • Gisa and Geralf

    Gisa and Geralf

  • Shelob, Child of Ungoliant

    Shelob, Child of Ungoliant

  • Mox Jasper

    Mox Jasper

  • Scaled Nurturer

    Scaled Nurturer

Gameplay Summary

The game features a dynamic and thematic clash among four Kindred commanders, each representing a distinct creature type: spiders, slivers, zombies, and dragons.

Early turns see players establishing their mana bases and deploying key early creatures to support their tribal synergies.

Shelob’s spider deck develops a defensive posture with reach creatures, while The First Sliver quickly establishes flying slivers to assert aerial dominance.

Gisa and Geralf’s zombie deck begins milling to fuel graveyard recursion, steadily building a resilient undead threat.

Ureni’s dragon deck leverages ramp and powerful flying dragons like Chaos Dragon, which forces players into tense decisions due to its attack restrictions based on dice rolls. Midgame momentum shifts as Gisa and Geralf start casting zombies from the graveyard, increasing board presence and threatening to overwhelm opponents.

The First Sliver’s ability to grant flying to all slivers makes ground defense difficult for other players, especially against the spider deck that relies on reach.

Meanwhile, the dragon deck uses life gain and aggressive creatures to pressure opponents while managing the randomness of Chaos Dragon’s combat trigger.

Key turning points include Gisa and Geralf’s milling triggers and zombie recursion, alongside the First Sliver’s board-wide flying buff, challenging opponents to respond quickly or face aerial assaults.

The game ultimately revolves around these tribal synergies outpacing one another, with victory hinging on leveraging tribal strengths and well-timed removal or combat maneuvers.

Watch on YouTube