The BEST BUDGET The Hobbit Commander Decks | EDH GAMEPLAY thumbnail Blurred backdrop thumbnail

The BEST BUDGET The Hobbit Commander Decks | EDH GAMEPLAY

ScryBabies profile icon
ScryBabies 104 EDH Gameplay videos

Commanders featured in this Gameplay Reviewed & Verified

Decklists

Deck & Commander Strategies

  • Thorin, King of Durin's Folk

    Thorin, King of Durin's Folk

    Build a dwarf tribal deck focused on generating treasure tokens and leveraging artifact synergies to buff dwarfs and control combat, using equipment and story enchantments to enhance board presence and defense.

  • The Great Goblin

    The Great Goblin

    Aggressively apply damage through counters on goblin-orc armies and sacrifice triggers, generating card advantage by exiling and playing cards from the top of the library when creatures die.

  • Gandalf, Wandering Wizard

    Gandalf, Wandering Wizard

    Utilize card draw and repeated adventures with Gandalf to outvalue opponents, aiming for a late-game win through incremental advantage without alternate combo win conditions.

  • The Notary Hobbits

    The Notary Hobbits

    Ramp quickly into a large mana base producing massive amounts of colorless mana to cast big, impactful colorless spells and dominate the board with powerful threats.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    The Great Goblin’s ability to deal damage to all opponents whenever counters are put on goblin-orc armies created constant pressure and forced opponents to respond quickly.

  • 2

    Treasure tokens generated by Thorin and other dwarfs enabled explosive mana acceleration and buffed creatures, creating an intimidating board state early on.

  • 3

    Exiling and casting cards from the top of the library via Goblin orc deaths gave the Great Goblin player card advantage and surprise resources, shifting momentum in their favor.

  • 4

    Gandalf's deck emphasized a slower, value-based strategy relying on repeated commander adventures and card draw without alternate win conditions, requiring patience and careful resource management.

  • 5

    The Notary Hobbits deck’s ramp into large amounts of colorless mana allowed it to deploy expensive, game-changing colorless spells, threatening to outclass opponents with raw power.

Notable Cards

  • Thorin, King of Durin's Folk

    Thorin, King of Durin's Folk

  • Wild Growth

    Wild Growth

  • Thought Vessel

    Thought Vessel

Gameplay Summary

The game featured four unique Hobbit-themed Commander decks, each with a distinct tribal or thematic focus.

Early turns were spent setting up mana bases and developing board presence, with players gradually casting their commanders and synergistic creatures.

The Great Goblin deck focused on dealing incremental damage through counters on a goblin-orc army and leveraging card advantage by exiling and playing cards from the top of the library whenever creatures died.

The Notary Hobbits deck aimed to generate large amounts of colorless mana quickly to cast big, impactful colorless spells.

Gandalf's deck revolved around drawing cards and sending the commander on repeated adventures to fuel a late-game finish, while the Thorin, King of Durin's Folk deck prioritized dwarf tribal synergies, treasure token generation, and artifact support to buff creatures and lock down opponents with defensive effects. A turning point came as the players started producing treasure tokens and applying pressure through combat damage and board control effects.

The Great Goblin player used sacrifice triggers and damage pings to wear down opponents, while the Thorin deck established a strong board with artifact-enhanced dwarfs and defensive story enchantments.

The Notary Hobbits player aimed to ramp mana explosively, threatening to cast powerful colorless spells, and Gandalf's deck played a slower, card-drawing gameplan to outvalue opponents.

The game showcased a mix of aggressive and control tactics, with synergy-driven tribal strategies and resource management shaping the flow.

Ultimately, these budget Hobbit decks demonstrated how flavorful tribal themes could still deliver interactive and engaging Commander gameplay.

Watch on YouTube