Smaug VS Thorin VS Beorn VS Elrond | The Hobbit Commander Gameplay! thumbnail Blurred backdrop thumbnail

Smaug VS Thorin VS Beorn VS Elrond | The Hobbit Commander Gameplay!

KingdomsTV profile icon
KingdomsTV 295 EDH Gameplay videos

Commanders featured in this Gameplay Reviewed & Verified

Decklists

Deck & Commander Strategies

  • Smaug the Magnificent

    Smaug the Magnificent

    Generate numerous treasure tokens to fuel powerful combat damage and burn spells, using Smaug's ability to deal damage equal to the number of treasures controlled to any target, aiming to win through overwhelming direct damage.

  • Elrond, Moon-Reader

    Elrond, Moon-Reader

    Focus on activating creature abilities each turn to draw cards and control the board, utilizing a tap-activation theme with creatures that benefit from repeated ability use and leveraging exile-and-return effects for resilience.

  • Beorn the Fierce

    Beorn the Fierce

    Swarm the board with bears and other creatures, buffing them with trample counters and anthem effects, drawing cards when controlling three or more bears, aiming to win through overwhelming ground combat damage.

  • Thorin, Mountain-king

    Thorin, Mountain-king

    Utilize dwarf tribal synergies with axes, hammers, and combat buffs to generate big swings in combat, focusing on aggressive attacking and leveraging dwarf-specific tribal support spells and creatures.

Gameplay Insights

  • 1

    Smaug player leveraged Inspiring Tinkerer to exile cards and create multiple treasure tokens, enabling a high-impact Embercleave equip that drastically increased Smaug's damage output.

  • 2

    Redirection of a burn spell to protect Smaug demonstrated smart use of interaction to maintain board presence while mitigating incoming damage.

  • 3

    Elrond's tap-dancing deck consistently activated abilities to draw cards and control the battlefield, using exile-and-return effects to reset threats and sustain advantage.

  • 4

    Beorn maximized his bear tribal synergy by accumulating trample counters and card draw triggers, building a threatening board state that pressured opponents.

  • 5

    Treasure tokens were a central resource for Smaug and other players, fueling both spells and combat damage, creating a tense dynamic around artifact management and damage calculation.

Notable Cards

  • Embercleave

    Embercleave

  • Generous Plunderer

    Generous Plunderer

  • Lightning Greaves

    Lightning Greaves

  • Grand Architect

    Grand Architect

  • Brass's Bounty

    Brass's Bounty

  • Ruby Medallion

    Ruby Medallion

  • Greater Good

    Greater Good

Gameplay Summary

The game featured a dynamic four-player Commander match with Smaug the Magnificent, Elrond Moon-Reader, Beorn the Fierce, and Thorin, Mountain-king leading their respective decks.

Early turns focused on ramping and setting up key pieces, with Smaug generating treasure tokens to fuel aggressive damage output, while Elrond's deck emphasized activating creature abilities to draw cards and control the board.

Beorn aimed to swarm with bears and utilize his anthem and trample counters to push through damage, and Thorin led a dwarf tribal strategy focusing on axes, hammers, and combat synergy. A pivotal moment occurred when Smaug's player cast Inspiring Tinkerer, exiling cards to generate multiple treasure tokens and then equipped Embercleave to Smaug, massively increasing his damage potential.

This forced opponents to respond, with one player redirecting a burn spell to protect themselves and Smaug simultaneously.

Beorn's board presence grew with multiple bears and card draw triggers, but the overwhelming treasure and damage output from Smaug kept the table under pressure.

Elrond's tap-dancing mechanic allowed for steady card advantage and tactical plays, including exiling and returning creatures to disrupt opponents.

The game demonstrated high interaction around the treasure mechanic and aggressive combat phases, with Smaug emerging as a significant threat through treasure-fueled damage and combat triggers.

Watch on YouTube